Research

MUFG Out? SMBC Wins? PAINin Volatility Continues

market-avatar

Algo Research Team


The content provided here is for informational purpose only. It is not an advise or recommendation. Please do your own research.
content-img

Key Summary:


  • The saga for corporate action in Panin Group continues
  • BDMN's share price down, but BTPN's is up?
  • Market seems to be pricing in SMBC as the winner to buy PNBN

"Buy on rumor, sell on news". This theme or trading strategy (not an investment advice) is always there every year and especially a recurring theme for the banking sector due to continued push by the regulator to consolidate the players. 2017-18 were BDMN, BTPN, 2019 was BNLI, 2020 was BRIS, 2021 was BANK, BBHI, BNBA and this year the hot topic is on PNBN in 2022. The quest for corporate action for PNBN has been in the market for the past 7 years as traders continue to speculate if there will be divestment or outright sales of Panin Bank. We do not know. But, market seems to be very convinced this year, even more so than previous years in 2015/2017/2019 when the rumor appeared. You can see this clearly in the share price (which shows what the market expects) at all time high for PNBN and the other Panin Group (PNLF, PNIN).



Now let's entertain the rumor, assuming that this is the case, who are the bidders? MUFG and SMBC seem to be the contestants. The next question is why these two banks? It's simple, its all margins. Japanese banks don't make much margins in Japan with negative yielding interest rates, but they do make money in Indonesia where NIM is 6-7% on average. Historically, they can borrow cheaply in Yen (though now Yen has imploded, a 20-30% decrease against major peers, even against IDR) and finance expansion abroad with Indonesian banking sector looking very attractive comparatively to other EMs in South East Asia. They have already done so by buying BDMN and BTPN, respectively.


How was our research?


DISCLAIMER: Algo is an independent research platform and is not affiliated with any financial institution. We are not a licensed securities dealer, financial advisor, broker, or investment bank. The contents shared across our website, and social media platforms are intended for informational purposes only and reflect our views and opinions. It is not meant to be construed as financial advice and/or a recommendation to buy or sell an asset. Past performance does not guarantee future results. As a research platform, our contents are made to provide data-driven information and research-based articles, and should not be used as a basis for making any investment decisions. We strongly encourage you to conduct your own research and consult with a licensed financial advisor before making any investment decisions. Algo is not regulated by OJK (Otoritas Jasa Keuangan) and does not provide any investment services. We are not responsible for any financial decisions you make based on the information provided. All content is presented with the intent of informing only.